Single Family

61 Cartwright Road

Pending · Shelter Island · Suffolk County, NY 11964

Asking price$2,230,000Estimate monthly payment Check current status

Bedrooms: 5 Beds
Bathrooms: 4 Baths
Year built: 1858
Est. monthly taxes: $631.59

0 of 33 photos ready

About this home

Set on a well-proportioned acre in one of Shelter Island’s most sought-after neighborhoods, this 1850s farmhouse offers charm, generous living space, and an exceptional location, with room for a pool. The main level features a spacious living room with a wood-burning fireplace, a dining room with a second wood-burning fireplace, and a bright sunroom. The open kitchen offers two exterior doors leading to side porches, providing an inviting connection to the outdoors and an ideal setting for entertaining. Upstairs are five generously sized bedrooms and three full bathrooms. A full basement and attic provide ample storage and utility space. Just a stone’s throw from Coecles Harbor Marina, this property presents an opportunity to enjoy the tranquility of Shelter Island.

Listing snapshot

Days on site: 20 days
Listed on MLS: Oct 8, 2026
Full baths: 4
Half baths: 0
Annual property tax (MLS): $7,579.08
Tax year: 2026
Area source (MLS): Public Records
Listing brokerage: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
MLS ID: KEY1058792
Last updated: Oct 21, 2026

General features

Property type: Single Family
Property subtype: Single Family Residence
Year built: 1858
Garage: Yes
Garage spaces: 1
Parking: Driveway, Garage
Water source: Well
Sewer: Septic Tank
Utilities: Cable Available, Electricity Available, Propane, Water Connected

Interior features

Basement: Full, Partially Finished, Walk-Out Access
Heating: Baseboard, Hot Water, Propane
Cooling: Wall/Window Unit(s)
Interior: First Floor Full Bath, Eat-in Kitchen, Formal Dining
Appliances: Dishwasher, Exhaust Fan, Gas Cooktop, Gas Oven, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s)
Flooring: Wood
Fireplace: Yes
Fireplaces: 2

Exterior features

Architectural style: Colonial, Farmhouse
Construction materials: HardiPlank Type
Private pool: No

Schools (MLS)

Elementary school: Shelter Island School
Elementary school district: Shelter Island
Middle school: Shelter Island School
Middle school district: Shelter Island
High school: Shelter Island School
High school district: Shelter Island

School information is provided by the MLS. Confirm attendance eligibility with the school district.

Recent activity

Oct 21, 2026Listing updated from MLS
Oct 20, 2026MLS status changed
Oct 8, 2026First seen on this site

Location

Shelter Island · Suffolk County, NY 11964Show interactive map

61 Cartwright Road

Shelter Island · Suffolk County, NY 11964

Google Maps directions

Estimate monthly payment

Payment method

Loan detailsFixed-rate, fully amortizing loan. Edit the assumptions below; no market rate is supplied.

Down payment %Interest rate %Term

Property expenses (USD)

Annual property taxMonthly association / maintenance fees

Does the management / maintenance fee include property tax?MLS amounts are prefilled when available and can be edited. Confirm what fees include. Unknown fee frequencies cannot be converted automatically.Property expenses: MLS values where available; missing values stay blank.

Estimated monthly principal & interest—

Monthly property taxNot provided

Monthly association / maintenance feesNot provided

Estimated monthly total of entered costs—

Excludes insurance, mortgage insurance, special assessments and lender fees. MLS taxes may reflect abatements or exemptions and can change.

Listing data is supplied by the MLS and may change without notice.

Check current status